1. The Reverend Mr. David Tease — 1870 - 1894
  2. The Reverend Mr. Samuel P. Massie — 1894 - 1902
  3. The Reverend Mr. George H. Ray — 1902 - 1912
  4. The Reverend Mr. J. A. Thomas — 1914 - 1919
  5. The Reverend Mr. Clyde J. Walsh— 1919 - 1925
  6. The Reverend Mr. Jonathan Edwards— 1925 - 1928
  7. The Reverend Mr. J. Hoge Smith — 1929 - 1941
  8. The Reverend Mr. George Bird Talbot — 1942 - 1947
  9. The Reverend Mr. R. R. Ramsey — 1951 - 1954
  10. The Reverend Mr. Charles E. Sutton — 1955 - 1961
  11. The Reverend Mr. J. Renwick Kennedy — 1962 - 1968
  12. The Reverend Mr. Harold V. Kuhn — 1969 - 1974
  13. The Reverend Dr. L. Wayne Meredith — 1976 - 1984
  14. The Reverend Mr. D. Barrett Tucker — 1986 - present